JOHN D'SOUZA VS EDWARD
ANI 17 DECEMBER 1993
PETITIONER: JOHN D'SOUZA RESPONDENT: EDWARD ANI
BENCH: Justice Pandian S R, Justice Sawant P B
CITATION: 1994 AIR 975 ,1994 SCC (2)64 1993 SUPL. 327 ,1993 SCALE (4)702
LAWS INVOLVED : Advocates
Act, 1961-section 35 Professional misconduct
FACTS:
It is about a married couple N.E.
Raymond and Mrs Mary Raymond. Mary Raymond made a 'will' which was drafted by
advocate John D'souza. N.E. Raymond was made as the executor of will. John
D'souza gave a receipt dated 5 Jul 1968 for entry in the register of wills, as
Mrs Mary Raymond had entrusted that 'will' with advocate John D'souza. But before
wife, husband N.E. Raymond died in 1974. Mary Raymond changed her lawyer and
made Mr George D'Costa as her advocate. Advocate George the Costa requested the
appellant advocate John D'souza to return the 'will', but he denied having it. Thereafter,
Mrs Mary Raymond was obliged to make another will prepared by Mr George DaCosta
on 24 Jun 1978.
Advocate John D'souza filed the stay petition for the same, under section 14(2) of Advocate's act and appeal before the Supreme Court.
ISSUES:
Weather an act of
the advocate, not handing over the will in his custody to the client, amounts
to professional misconduct?
JUDGEMENT:
The responded has proved that, the appellant and had not return the will, appellant has changed his stand and denied having the 'will' later he said that, he had return it in 1982, there is no such proof, he was bound in duty to return the said will when demanded. The appeal is accordingly dismissed, and the stay granted by the court shall stand vacated.
Supreme Court held that the advocate has committed breach of his professional duty and found him guilty of professional misconduct. The Supreme Court further stated that the conduct of appellant not returning the will even on demand is unworthy of an advocate belonging to a noble profession. The appeal dismissed and the stay granted Supreme Court shell stand vacated. No cost.
Reference
(166) JOHN D'SOUZA VS EDWARD ANI,1994 - YouTube
No comments:
Post a Comment